Your office lists a house. A buyer finds it on Zillow and clicks Contact Agent. Zillow often sends that inquiry to an agent who paid for the ZIP code. Sometimes that agent is one of yours, paying to win back a buyer your own listing brought in. As one agent put it: “we are paying companies to beat us in the search results so that they can sell the leads back to us.”
This guide covers what you can change, what you can’t, and how your own website fits in. All of it is based on public reporting through October 2026.
Can a brokerage stop paying Zillow for leads on its own listings?
Partly. You can’t decide who gets a Contact Agent click on Zillow. That is Zillow’s call. You can do three things, though. You can give buyers your own website to land on. You can use the portal channels that send inquiries to the listing agent. And you can cut paid portal spend in the ZIP codes where you already hold many listings.
Here are the two money leaks to keep apart:
- Direct spend: what you pay for portal ads each month or in referral fees at closing.
- Lost buyers: buyers who found your listing but ended up with another agent.
Your own site helps with both. Each buyer who starts on your site is one you don’t have to buy back.
Why can’t our brokerage just pull its listings off Zillow?
No, in most cases you can’t opt out of Zillow alone. Zillow gets listings through the same IDX feed (the MLS data feed brokerages use on their websites) that other brokers get. Since 2021, CRMLS in Southern California has said brokers can’t exclude Zillow by itself for that reason.
Holding listings back has its own risk too. Zillow’s Listing Access Standards started with warnings on May 28, 2025, and enforcement on June 30, 2025. Here is how they work:
- A listing that is publicly marketed (a yard sign, social media, a private office network) must be on the MLS and on Zillow within one business day.
- After two warnings, Zillow can ban that listing for the life of the listing agreement.
- Compass sued over this rule. A federal judge in New York denied its request to block the rule on February 6, 2026. Compass dropped the suit on March 18, 2026.
Some MLSs let a seller delay showing a listing on IDX sites and portals. This comes from NAR’s “Multiple Listing Options for Sellers” policy, which MLSs had to put in place by September 30, 2025. The seller must sign a consent form, and not every MLS adopted it (CRMLS and MLS Now did not). Delaying a listing is a seller choice, not a way for your office to dodge lead fees.
Who gets the inquiry when a buyer clicks Contact Agent on your listing?
It depends on the portal. On Zillow, Contact Agent usually goes to a paying Premier Agent, not the listing agent. On Homes.com, it goes to the listing agent. On your own website, it goes wherever you set it up to go.
| Where the buyer clicks | Who usually gets the inquiry, based on public reporting |
|---|---|
| Zillow (regular listing) | Paying Premier Agents in rotation, based on how much of the ZIP code each one bought |
| Zillow Preview (pre-market listings from participating brokerages) | The listing agent |
| Realtor.com | Paying agents. Depending on the plan, one agent or several may get the same lead |
| Homes.com | The listing agent, under its “Your Listing, Your Lead” policy |
| Your own website | The agent or inbox you choose |
Zillow’s own page says it checks whether a buyer is ready, then calls its Premier Agents in rotation. It also says that if a buyer picks a specific agent, that agent gets the contact. Analyst Mike DelPrete says the button “rarely” goes to the listing agent.
This is being fought in court. In Taylor v. Zillow, filed September 19, 2025, in federal court in Seattle, buyers claim they thought Contact Agent reached the listing agent. We found no public update on the case after December 2025.
These rules change, so ask your Zillow and Realtor.com reps how routing works for your listings today. Get the answer in writing.
How much do Zillow and Realtor.com leads cost a brokerage?
Portal leads usually cost a share of the commission at closing or a monthly ad budget. Zillow Flex referral fees are reported at 15% to 40% of the agent’s commission. Neither Zillow nor Realtor.com publishes one official rate, so treat every number below as a reported range.
| Program | How you pay | Reported cost |
|---|---|---|
| Zillow Flex | Referral fee when the deal closes | 15% to 40% of the agent’s commission. The top fee rose to 40% in October 2023, and most markets fall in that band |
| Zillow Premier Agent | Monthly ad spend by ZIP code | Not confirmed. One secondary source says about $200 to $1,800 a month |
| Realtor.com ReadyConnect Concierge | Referral fee when the deal closes | Not confirmed. Reports range from 28% to 40% |
| Homes.com | Membership | Homes.com says it takes no commission and doesn’t sell your listing leads. We found no public price list |
You’ll see older articles say Flex is “35%.” That is out of date for most markets. Check your own agreement.
What is Zillow Preview, and does it help with lead fees?
Zillow Preview is a channel for pre-market listings, launched March 17, 2026. On a Preview listing, Contact Agent goes straight to the listing agent. If that buyer later buys through one of Zillow’s partner agents, Zillow pays the listing agent 10% of the buy-side commission out of Zillow’s own share.
What to know before you count on it:
- Only participating brokerages can use it. The launch group was Keller Williams, HomeServices, RE/MAX, Side and United Real Estate. More than 60 brokerages reportedly take part now.
- It covers pre-market listings sent straight to Zillow, not your active MLS listings.
- Buyers can’t tour until the listing goes active.
- In May 2026, Realtor.com agreed to show Preview listings on the same terms.
- Outlets call the 10% a “referral fee,” a “bonus” or a “payment.” We could not confirm any time limit on which purchases count.
If your brokerage isn’t in Preview, ask Zillow whether you can join. Once a listing goes active on the MLS, the regular routing applies again.
How to keep inquiries on your own listings inside the brokerage
The fix is a plan, not one switch. You track what you spend, put your listings on your own site, send every inquiry to the right agent, and drive buyers there from everything you control. Here are the steps, in order.
- Find your number. Tag every portal lead in your CRM (the software that holds your contacts) with one question: was this one of our listings? Add up what those leads cost, including referral fees on closed deals. That is the money you are trying to win back.
- Put your office listings on your own site. With MLS Import, an import task (a saved rule that pulls listings from your MLS) can bring in only your office’s listings. You filter on your office ID. In the MLS data, that field is called ListOfficeMlsId or ListOfficeKey, and which one works depends on your MLS. You can also pull the whole market as a search tool. See importing one agent’s or one office’s listings.
- Attach each listing to its agent. Run one import task per agent and choose that agent in Select Agent. Then the listing shows up on the right agent profile. On WpEstate, the agent you pick is not added to imported listings. Set the agent with a bulk edit after each import. See office and agent pages without duplicate listings.
- Send each lead to the listing agent. In standalone mode (MLS Import running on any theme), a form on a property page goes to the agent linked to that listing. If no agent is linked, it goes to your company email, then to your WordPress admin email. On WpResidence, Houzez, Real Homes and WpEstate, the theme’s own forms do the routing. See where property leads are sent.
- Point everything you control at your site. Put your web address and a QR code on yard signs, flyers, open house sign-in sheets, emails and social posts. Link straight to the listing page on your domain, not to the portal.
- Give buyers a reason to come back. Saved searches let a buyer leave her name and email and get at most one email a day when a matching listing is added or updated. Your site sends it, not Zillow. This works in MLS Import’s standalone mode. See saved searches on your own site.
- Get leads into your CRM. MLS Import emails leads and doesn’t save them on the site. To push them into a CRM, use your theme’s webhook settings, or have a developer hook into the plugin’s lead action. See sending property leads to a CRM.
- Check again in 90 days. Look at your number from step 1 again. If your paid portal spend sits in ZIP codes where you hold lots of listings, start cutting there.
Put the QR code on the sign rider and have it open the listing page on your own site. A buyer standing at the curb is the warmest lead you’ll ever get. Don’t send her to a portal to find you! Then submit a test inquiry from your phone and make sure it lands in the listing agent’s inbox. Here is how lead routing works.
What if you are a solo agent or a small team?
Your own listings are only a few homes. A buyer wants to see every home in their price range, and if only Zillow shows them, they search on Zillow. So pull the wider market onto your site as well, with a second import task, and give each area its own page.
With MLS Import, the city, ZIP, county and subdivision names in your listings become pages on your site, and each page lists the homes for sale there. Add a few lines of your own about each area, like the street that floods or where the school bus stops. Portals don’t have that. See how an independent brokerage competes with Zillow and Redfin in its own town.
MLS Import Alerts then sends you one email a day with the buyers whose saved searches match a new or changed listing, so you know who to call when a price drops.
At your next buyer meeting, set up the buyer’s saved search on your site with them, on their phone. Their new-listing emails then come from you, not from Zillow.
What your own site will not fix
Your own site won’t change how Zillow or Realtor.com route clicks. A buyer who never leaves the portal still goes to whoever paid. Your site wins the buyers you send there yourself.
Other limits to plan for:
- You need approval from your MLS before listings show up. Some boards take weeks. See MLS approval processes that take time.
- Leads are emailed, not saved on the site. If your host drops an email, WordPress can’t get it back. Set up a good mail plugin (SMTP) or a CRM link before you launch.
- MLS Import doesn’t connect to a CRM by itself. You use your theme’s settings or a developer hook.
- Forced registration (making visitors sign up before they see more) comes from your theme, not from MLS Import.
- Your site needs traffic you create: signs, ads, email and social.
Frequently asked questions about portal fees on your own listings
Will our brokerage site get as much traffic as Zillow?
No. As one agent said, “You will never beat Zillow, Compass, Redfin, etc” on raw traffic. That’s fine. The goal is narrower: buyers you already reach with signs, ads, email and social should land on your listing page, not a portal’s.
Can our brokerage keep its listings off Zillow?
No, not in most markets. Zillow gets listings through the same IDX feed other brokers use. Its Listing Access Standards can also ban a publicly marketed listing that isn’t on the MLS and Zillow within one business day. A seller can sometimes delay portal display with signed consent, if your MLS allows it.
Do we have to drop Premier Agent or Flex to do this?
No. Many offices keep some portal spend and cut it where their own listings sit. Your own site lowers how many of your own listing inquiries you have to buy back.
Track the cost per closing for each lead source. Cut a portal ZIP code once your own site brings in closings there for less.
Does Homes.com send our listing leads to our agent?
Yes, by its own account. Homes.com says inquiries on a listing go only to the listing agent, and that it never sells those leads or takes a commission. That claim comes from CoStar, which owns Homes.com and competes with Zillow, so test it with your own listings.
Can each agent get their own listings page?
Yes. Run one import task per agent and choose that agent in Select Agent, and each agent’s page shows their listings. See office and agent pages without duplicate listings.
What happens to listing leads when an agent leaves?
They keep going to that agent until you move the listings. A lead goes to the agent linked to the listing, so change the agent on that agent’s import task. In standalone mode, the listings move at the next sync. On WpResidence, Houzez, Real Homes and WpEstate, old listings keep their agent, so bulk edit them to the new agent. See importing agents and showing listings by agent.
Can leads take turns between agents, like round robin?
Not by itself. MLS Import sends each property lead to one person: the listing’s agent, or your office email when no agent is linked. For round robin, send your leads to a CRM that does it. See sending property leads to a CRM.
Can one site show two MLS boards?
Yes. MLS Import can connect up to 7 MLS boards to one website. More than one board needs a multi-MLS plan. Each board keeps its own login and import tasks. See connecting two MLS boards to one site.
How long does setup take?
It depends mostly on your MLS. Board approval is usually the slow part, and some boards take weeks, so ask your board first. MLS Import includes help setting up your import.
Where do your own listing leads come from today? Tell us in the comments!