In real estate, generating a large number of leads—people who are considering buying or selling a house—is just the beginning. Some agents collect hundreds or even thousands of these leads every month. However, despite having all those names and numbers, they still struggle to make sales. On the other hand, some agents don’t have nearly as many leads, but they stay busy, book appointments regularly, and close deals.
So what’s the difference? It’s not always about the number of people you talk to. What matters is how well you follow up after someone shows interest. A well-organized system keeps follow-up on track, and easy-to-use tools like like WP Residence and MLSImport provide the extra support you need to do it right.
This article explains how to convert online leads into real clients, even if they’re not ready to buy or sell immediately. We’ll go step-by-step, using real numbers, simple ideas, and innovative tools that are built into WordPress. By the end, you’ll understand how to keep people engaged and help them move forward—at their own pace.
Why Most Real Estate Leads Don’t Turn Into Sales (Yet)
Let’s start with the numbers. According to the National Association of Realtors, many agents close fewer than 1 out of every 100 leads. That means they talk to 100 people before someone buys or sells a home. Some top agents do better—they might close 1 in 10—but it takes time, skill, and the right system.
Many of these leads originate from prominent websites like Zillow or Realtor.com. These sites provide agents with access to numerous individuals searching for homes. But many of those people are just browsing. They might be thinking about moving in six months or even a year from now.
Even so, the best real estate teams are converting 7% to 9% of the warmest leads they get from Realtor.com. That means if they get 100 good leads, they can turn 7 to 9 of them into real sales. This doesn’t happen by chance. It happens because these agents use the right tools to keep in touch, build trust, and help people when they’re ready.
So what makes the difference? The best agents:
- Tag leads inside a CRM (Customer Relationship Manager) so they know who’s ready now and who’s not
- Follow up slowly and steadily over time—even with people who don’t respond right away
- Use automation tools to stay in touch without needing to write every message by hand
Tools like FluentCRM and Groundhogg accomplish this within WordPress. They help you send smart emails, remember who clicked on what, and show you which leads are getting warmer—so you don’t miss a chance.
Buyers Use the Internet Differently Today
A lot has changed in the past 10 years. Back then, most people called a real estate agent early in their home search. They wanted to talk and ask questions right away. However, almost everyone has now started online. They use their phones to look at listings, scroll through social media, and read reviews before ever calling an agent.
Let’s look at some facts: almost half of today’s homebuyers are millennials, and they like to do their research first. Most use multiple devices, switching from phones to computers to tablets and many spend 10 to 15 hours a week looking at homes on social media or websites.
That’s why your website is more important than ever. If your site is slow, hard to use, or doesn’t show good listings, people won’t stick around. They’ll just go back to Zillow or another big site.
This is why WP Residence is such an innovative tool for agents. WP Residence is a WordPress theme made just for real estate. It gives your website all the tools buyers want, like:
- A map search so people can explore neighborhoods easily
- Fast, mobile-friendly design that works on any screen
- Login areas where visitors can save their favorite homes
- Forms that connect directly to your CRM so you can track interest
And the best part? WP Residence works seamlessly with MLSImport.com. MLS Import allows you to display real MLS listings directly on your site, with listings updating automatically. That means your site will always show the newest, most accurate homes—just like the big platforms do.
Imagine this: a buyer is browsing Zillow and comes across a home they like. Then they visit your site and see the same house, with even more local details. That’s powerful. It makes your site feel trustworthy, and it helps buyers see you as the local expert.
Paid Lead Sites Like Zillow Might Not Be Enough
Now, some agents still pay for leads from Zillow, Realtor.com, or other platforms. And for some, that has worked in the past. Some agents claim to have sold millions of homes thanks to those leads. However, others argue that those days are essentially behind us.
Here’s why: many of these platforms now send leads to multiple agents at once. That means that as soon as a buyer fills out a form, several agents receive the same information. It becomes a race to call first, and often, the buyer isn’t even ready to talk.
Worse still, some leads come from merely curious people. They aren’t planning to move any time soon. That means you can waste a lot of time on conversations that don’t go anywhere—unless you have a better system in place.
And guess what? You can build that better system inside WordPress, using tools like FluentCRM and Groundhogg, and connect it to your website powered by WP Residence.
Smart Follow-Up Tips That Work
The best agents don’t just make one call and give up. They follow up again and again—but they do it in a way that feels friendly and helpful, not pushy. Here’s how they do it:
- Send a quick message—by email or text—right after someone signs up
- Add the person into an email campaign that sends tips and listings over time
- Use CRM tags to mark each lead as “just browsing,” “interested,” or “hot,” and set reminders to check in
This process doesn’t just keep your leads warm—it shows them that you care. Even if they’re not ready yet, they’ll remember you when they are.
Inside WordPress, you can set all of this up to run automatically. That means you don’t need to remember who to email each week—it happens automatically.
Social Ads Can Bring Better Leads for Less
Let’s talk about Facebook and Instagram. These are not just places to post vacation photos—they’re also powerful advertising tools. And real estate agents are starting to see just how useful they can be.
Right now, the average click-through rate for real estate ads on Facebook is 2.4%. That’s better than many other industries. With proper targeting, agents are generating 40 to 50 leads from a single campaign—and spending significantly less than they would on Zillow.
These leads often perform better because you can choose exactly who sees your ad. For example, you can target individuals who have recently obtained a new job, gotten married or visited other real estate websites.
Once they click, they land on a specially designed page created just for them. With WordPress builders like Elementor, Bricks, or Kadence, you can create pages that look amazing and match your brand.
And when those leads fill out a form (using tools like WPForms or Gravity Forms), their info goes straight into your CRM. You can then follow up using the same innovative system we talked about earlier.
Want to know where your best leads are coming from? Use Pretty Links or WP Statistics to track what links people click and which ads are working.
Listings Must Always Be Up to Date
There’s one thing buyers hate: seeing listings that are already sold or have been taken off the market. If your site displays old or outdated homes, people will lose trust in it and return to Zillow.
This is why MLSImport.com is so helpful. It connects your WordPress website directly to your local Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and keeps your listings up to date automatically. No more copying and pasting. No more manual updates. Just real-time homes, ready to view.
Pair MLS Import with WP Residence, and your website becomes a complete real estate platform. People can: search by map, save favorite homes, get email alerts when something new appears and compare listings side by side.
Other tools, such as IDX Broker and Realtyna, also assist with listing imports. However, MLS Import is fast, clean, and designed to work seamlessly with top WordPress themes, such as WP Residence.
Make Your System Do the Work
You can’t follow up with every lead manually. That’s why automation is so important. It helps you stay in touch without needing to do everything by hand.
Using Groundhogg or FluentCRM, you can leverage advanced features that enhance your email marketing and lead management capabilities. These tools allow you to create smart tags that automatically update based on each lead’s behavior.
This means your system becomes more intelligent over time, adapting to how your audience interacts with your content. You can also schedule and automate emails to ensure that each message is delivered at the right moment, increasing the chances of engagement.
Additionally, both platforms provide detailed tracking, allowing you to see which leads are opening your messages or clicking on specific listings, giving you valuable insights to refine your strategy.
It’s the System That Wins
Some agents chase lead after lead, hoping to find the perfect one. But intelligent agents know the truth: A good lead in a bad system is wasted. A weak lead in a great system can still close.
That’s why you need to build a system that works for you. Use:
- WP Residence to create a real estate site buyers will trust
- MLSImport.com to keep your listings fresh and up-to-date
- FluentCRM or Groundhogg to manage follow-ups and emails
Build it once, improve it over time, and let your system do the heavy lifting. Because when you focus on working the leads you already have—you’ll close more deals, build more trust, and grow your business the smart way.
Table of Contents
